CBC asks court docket to maintain Gem subscriber numbers confidential – Nationwide
CBC/Radio-Canada has filed an software in Federal Court docket to combat an order directing it to reveal subscriber numbers for its Gem streaming service.
The knowledge commissioner ordered CBC to make obtainable the variety of paid subscribers to Gem following an access-to-information request for the information.
CBC/Radio-Canada president Marie-Philippe Bouchard advised The Canadian Press the subscriber numbers are delicate business info.
That confidentiality issues relating to issues like business negotiations on bundling Gem with different streaming providers, Bouchard added.
The general public broadcaster is “charged with making a few of our finances out of business relationships,” she stated.
“And that must be performed in response to the principles of the market. And so we’re discovering ourselves, with this ruling, uncomfortable with the interpretation.”
In refusing to reveal the numbers, CBC cited exemptions for programming actions and knowledge that would hurt its aggressive place.
In her closing report on the access-to-information grievance, Info Commissioner Caroline Maynard stated the subscriber numbers relate to CBC’s programming actions, however additionally they relate to its basic administration — which implies the exemption to disclosure doesn’t apply.
Maynard stated whereas “CBC did establish potential harms to its aggressive place or to ongoing negotiations, it didn’t exhibit that there was an inexpensive expectation that these harms might happen, properly past a mere risk.”
The knowledge commissioner’s ruling contradicts the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Fee’s interpretation of what constitutes “delicate business info,” Bouchard stated.
Get every day Nationwide information
Get the day’s prime information, political, financial, and present affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox as soon as a day.
Bouchard stated CBC/Radio-Canada needs the courts to offer readability on the problem.
CBC launched the Gem streaming service, which has each paid and free variations, in 2018. The paid model, which prices $5.99 a month, consists of ad-free on-demand streaming and a stream of CBC’s 24-hour information channel, CBC Information Community.
Paid subscribers “are usually not what makes Gem,” Bouchard stated. “Gem is principally a free-to-user service. And the paid half is mostly a commodity for individuals who don’t need promoting.”
CBC doesn’t disclose the variety of paid or unpaid subscribers to Gem.
In its discover of software, CBC/Radio-Canada asks the court docket to put aside the knowledge commissioner’s order and declare that Gem information are exempt from disclosure.
It argues the general public broadcaster “operates in a extremely aggressive surroundings by which overseas and home personal and group broadcasters and different digital streamers supply their very own programming on their respective distribution platforms.”
Bouchard was pressed on the query Monday afternoon throughout an look on the Home of Commons heritage committee.
Conservative MP Kevin Waugh requested Bouchard whether or not she was “embarrassed” by the quantity.
“No,” she responded.
“Why don’t you come out and simply say, right here’s the numbers that we obtained,” Waugh requested once more, telling Bouchard to “give us some numbers.”
Bouchard responded that greater than 5 million individuals have created an account.
In a later change with Waugh, Bouchard stated the CRTC permits companies to “contemplate that info confidential,” whereas the knowledge commissioner’s interpretation “says that we have now not met the usual for that confidentiality.”
“We would like reconciliation between these two interpretations, and that’s why we requested the Federal Court docket to think about the scenario,” she stated.
Waugh disagreed, telling Bouchard: “I don’t know what you’re hiding. I actually don’t, since you’re a public broadcaster, you’re getting the funds from the general public, and also you’re not in competitors with Bell Media, Crave or any of these.”
© 2025 The Canadian Press
